Style Imitating Art: Thanksgiving!

Style Imitating Art…

Welcome back for my interpretation of a piece of seasonal art!  Salazar, Shelbee, and I are the curators. You can think of this series as fashion meets art museum! SIA challenges people to find inspiration in different art works, create looks based upon that art work, and share them with the curator for that piece. Shelbee chose this colorful and happy painting for us, and I really like it. I hope you enjoy this post, the information, and my interpretation.

How it works…

Every other Monday one of us selects an inspiration piece of art and posts the image on their blog. We then invite others to interpret that art work through their style. The following Monday, we share our outfits. The curator shares submissions the following Wednesday on her blog. Shelbee chose this week’s art work for this round of Style Imitating Art. If you’d like, you can read why she chose it here. Please send your photo to Shelbee by Tuesday, November 17th, 2026 by 10 pm EST. Style Imitating Art is an interesting way to inspire your outfits. You can see a few of my looks here, here, here, and here.

The artist…

Doris Emrick Lee was born in Aledo, Illinois on February 1, 1905 and is considered one of the most successful female artists of the Depression Era in the United States.  She attended Ferry Hall School which was a preparatory school for girls in Lake Forest, Illinois from 1920-1922. Lee’s middle class upbringing prepared her for a traditional life as a wife and mother.  Her only art training would have been an “occasional summer class at the Art Institute.”  Lee’s parents’ interest in her artistic ventures was minimal.  This was probably because the family was very creative.  Her grandparents were artistic as were her siblings.  So, her parents were both unimpressed with her talent as well as wanting her to pursue a traditional college education.  Lee attended Rockford College and was expelled more than once.  One time was because she bobbed her hair!  Lee, rather than following that trail to marriage, discovered learning could lead to more exciting things for her. She graduated in 1927 after majoring in art and philosophy. Shortly after graduation, she married Russell Werner Lee, an engineer. 

Early years…

The newlyweds spent their honeymoon in Italy and France.  The new Mrs. Lee studied at the Académie des Beaux-Arts.  Mr. Lee soon became interested in art as well and became a “noted photographer with the Farm Security Administration.” At first, Lee created abstract pieces of art due to the avant-garde art she’d studied.  Cubist painter, André Lhote, a buddy from her days in California, told her to “paint subjects” instead.  Lee found this “liberating.”  Isn’t that an interesting thought?  She’d been painting in a style that felt constrained, yet she did it.  More on that a bit later. 

Travels…

By 1929, Lee had already begun studying art at the Kansas City Art Institute.  One of the painters with whom she studied was the American Impressionist and Ashcan School painter, Ernest Lawson.  She also met Arnold Blanch while there.  The next year found Lee in San Francisco where she studied at the California School of Fine Arts.  As you can tell, the Lees moved around a lot, both for work and study.  Eventually, they settled in Woodstock, NY to be close to friends, Arnold and Lucile Blanch.  I got all excited about this move because I was just a little too young for the hippie movement and the Woodstock event.  Turns out, they are two different places.  The concert was held in Rome, NY which is about 150 miles away from Lee’s Woodstock. 

Woodstock…

This Woodstock seemed to be a bit like the Paris of New England.  Its “lush surrounding landscape, quaint farmhouses filled with folk art and lively artistic community filled with colorful, creative and highly social people gave Lee much in the way of ‘subjects’ to paint: fellow artists and neighbors appear in the vibrant “Beach Party;” paintings like “The View, Woodstock,” and “Dance Rehearsal” celebrate the town’s beauties along with its sense of community. ‘Moving to Woodstock for her was a pivotal decision,’ says Wolfe. ‘The group of artists there, the diversity of styles, the sort of bohemian-ness of it and yet the professionalism — I think she just flourished in that.’”

Divorce…

That wasn’t the only thing flourishing for Lee.  During this time, Lee and Blanch began an affair.  Eventually, she and Russell Lee divorced in 1939.  The Blanchs had divorced four years earlier.  Different sources say Lee and Blanch married; others say they were partners until he left her in the 60s.  In any event, the four remained on friendly terms. 

Creativity…

Lee’s creativity was seen in a huge range of media “including easel painting, murals, lithographs, book illustrations, record cover designs and even stage curtains. Dedicated and incredibly productive, there is ample justification for the widely shared opinion that she was one of America’s most successful women artists.”  In the 1930s, Lee was commissioned to create murals by the United States Treasury Department in Washington, DC.  She painted two murals in the Main Post Office there in 1937 and another in the Summerville, Georgia, Post Office.  In 1936, Lee had painted Catastrophe which was purchased by the Metropolitan Museum of Art.  Vladimir Nabokov’s book, Lolita, mentions her 1935 painting, Noon.  She also created a series of lithographs for the Associated American Artists as well as accepting many commissions for Life magazine.  These would take her to North Africa, Mexico, and Cuba. 

Thanksgiving…

In 1935, Lee painted the work that would make her famous, Thanksgiving.  Her painting became “the object of national headlines.”  Its “themes of Thanksgiving, rural customs, and family life, which Lee painted in a deliberately folksy manner, would have had great appeal to a country still in the midst of the national devastation of the Great Depression. Her painting offered a quaint model of domesticity that appealed to those who were tired of the complication of modern life in the 1930s. To a generation exhausted with the trials of economic hard times, the return to a simpler past became more desirable as the search for a new national identity continued. Her work received public and critical acclaim for its earthy qualities and sense of humor. One critic described her paintings as ‘fresh, with the charm of innocence’. Thanksgiving celebrates the joys of family ties. The bustling kitchen is filled with life and love as a group of women prepares the annual feast.” She received the Logan Medal of Arts at the 46th American Exhibition of Painting and Sculpture at the Art Institute of Chicago.  Mrs. Logan, whose husband endowed the prize, was not impressed with the “broad, exaggerated style and founded the conservative Society for Sanity in Art!”  Of course, that controversy just added to Lee’s fame. 

1930s…

The 1930s saw years of production for Lee. She created the many different art pieces I mentioned earlier as well as costumes, textiles, and ceramics. Her work centered around life in rural America, both stylistically and ideologically. “She portrayed the simple joys of American life in touching, nostalgic, and sometimes fanciful ways. Her paintings are sophisticated portrayals of color, mood, and design.” Her works appeared at the first Whitney Biennial exhibition in 1932. In 1936, Lee began to sell her works through the Maynard Walker Galleries. This relationship lasted until 1950. From 1936 to 1939, she was “invited to be a guest artist at the Colorado Springs Fine Arts Center.” She ended this decade on an extremely high note…an invitation to exhibit at the 1939 New York World’s Fair.

Success…

Lee and Blanch also began traveling to Florida.  While there, they met the painter, Milton Avery, and his wife, Sally Michel.  During the next two decades, Lee began painting in a more abstract style, “more stylized, more concerned with pure form and color.”  This was probably a result of Avery’s influence. She painted gardens, seasonal landscapes, and women and children on the beach.  These paintings were simple and flat.  In 1943 and 1944, she was a guest artist at Michigan State College in Lansing.  In 1944, she received the prestigious Carnegie Prize and “was included in fifteen of the annual juried exhibitions at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts.”  Following her travels to Central America and North Africa, Lee’s “paintings from this period, characterized by bold designs, evocative colors, whimsical subjects and ironic art historical references, established her unique position in the context of modern art in America.”  She also participated in one-woman and group exhibitions with the Associated American Artists Gallery and World House Galleries, both in New York City.

Finally…

Lee continued to paint throughout the 1960s, adapting her art to changing “trends” yet simultaneously remaining Doris Lee.  She retired from painting around 1968 after a diagnosis of Alzheimer’s Disease.  This left her unable to work.  “It was one barrier that she could not work or laugh her way through, as she did so many others, and it surely contributed to the art world forgetting her just as her own memory started to fail.”  “Co-curators Barbara Jones, of the Westmoreland, and Melissa Wolfe, of the St Louis Art Museum, argue that many interconnected factors contributed to the forgetting of Doris Lee.”  They argue Lee’s painting of figures as well as decorations and subjects people liked ultimately led to her art being dismissed as feminine and “incapable of serious meaning.”  I encourage you to read the Magpie post because it really gives you a deeper understanding, from Wolfe’s and Jones’ perspective, of Doris Lee.  It, somehow, makes her more human and understandable.  Doris Lee died in Clearwater, Florida on June 16, 1983.  She is entombed at the Emrick Mausoleum at Aledo Cemetery in Aledo, Illinois.

The artwork…

Thanksgiving was painted in 1935 and is oil on canvas. It measures 28 1/8 x 40 1/8 in (71.c x 101.8 cm) and is currently on permanent display at the Art Institute of Chicago. It was purchased from Doris Lee and has always belonged to the Art Institute. I have heard it said, though, that art once it leaves the artist belongs to everyone. I kinda like that, don’t you?

“Painted in a deliberately cartoon-like manner, this bustling scene of women preparing a Thanksgiving feast debuted in the midst of the Great Depression, a time when the themes of a national holiday, rural customs, and family life appealed to struggling Americans. It became the object of national headlines, however, when it was first exhibited at the Art Institute in 1935 and won the prestigious Logan Purchase Prize. Josephine Logan, the donor of the prize, condemned the work’s broad, exaggerated style as too modern, and founded the conservative “Sanity in Art” movement in response. This controversy only brought Illinois-born artist Doris Lee fame, and Thanksgiving has been recognized as one of the most popular views of this American ritual since that time.”

Sources…

Art Institute of Chicago

Wikipedia

Tidings of Magpies

US Department of State/Art in Embassies

D Wigmore Fine Art

National Museum of Women in the Arts

Learning Woodstock Community

My interpretation…

Ordinarily, I either really, really struggle with these challenges, or I know exactly what I’m going to wear. Well, Shelbee gave us so much to choose from. There is the pattern on the walls (had a dress for that). There’s the lady in the pink dress, and I had two choices for that. Then, there’s the lady in the middle with the basket. I had a teal dress for that. Of course, you already know what I chose, but what you don’t know is I let Nigel choose! This is the Twyla dress from April Cornell It’s on sale now in limited sizes. I’m wearing a small and almost wish I had gotten the XXS! April puts these nifty little button on ties so you can snatch your waist tighter or looser. Sometimes, I tie them in front which is what I did here. I have a couple of aprons, but when I put them on, they covered way too much of the dress. Then, I remembered how my Grandma Luderman would sometimes tuck a dishtowel in her waistband. This dress doesn’t have a waistband, but by tying it in the front, I could tuck this pretty little towel in place. I used to have a basket a lot like the one she’s carrying. I think I donated it at some point.

The Lewk!

I lucked out with shoes on this one! The two women whose shoes we can see are wearing either very dark brown or black shoes. Naturally, I went with my black Miz Mooz Freya flats which are on sale in very limited sizes. As far as I could tell, none of the women are wearing jewelry. I thought a couple of things when it came to jewelry. Lee painted Thanksgiving in 1935, right smack dab in the middle of the Great Depression. Women probably didn’t wear a lot of jewelry. If they did, it was probably something passed down from their moms. These earrings weren’t exactly passed down. They are old Stella & Dot, and my daughter gave them to me. So, they were passed up to her mom…me! I added the pretty lace tea towel so you could see the earrings and the lovely lace.

Wrap it up, Marsha!

I had never heard of Doris Lee before Shelbee chose this painting.  And, I think that’s sad.  This woman was responsible for so much creation, and only a few people (OK, probably several thousand) know of her.  I wonder if having Alzheimer’s back in 1968 made people turn away from her because it was so little understood.  Or, is it more than that?  So, can we talk? What is your favorite part of this painting?  What do you think of the two couples divorcing but remaining friends (even when two of the four became a couple)?  Why do you think we don’t know about Doris Lee? Please leave me a comment or two, and we can talk. I promise to respond as quickly as I can.

Don’t forget…

If you want to be included in the Style Imitating Art round up, send Shelbee your photo by 10:00 pm EST, November 17th, 2026. Photos of everyone participating will appear on her blog on Wednesday, November 18th! If you’re interested in joining us, consider all of your options…the colors, the textures, the feelings they evoke! Come on, give it a try! I think you’ll love it!

Thank you!

I want to thank all of you from the bottom of my heart for reading, commenting, subscribing or emailing! It truly means so much to me! If you’d like to follow me on Instagram, you can find me here.

Affiliate links, discount codes, and such:

Just a reminder that Marsha in the Middle may use an affiliate link. Those links are usually italicized. If you click or make a purchase from an italicized link I provide, I may receive a small commission at no cost to you. Thank you for your support.  My April Cornell code, MARSHA15, now works, but it’s good for only one use. You can get $15 off $100. I’d wait and use it during a really good sale! Use Marsha12 for 12% off any order of $65 or more at Buykud. I have also become a Halftee Partner. Use the code, MARSHA15, for 20% off any purchase. I am also an affiliate with Clara Sunwoo. You can use my code, MARSHA10, for 10% off your entire order. Use MARSHA15 at Katia Designs for 15% off your order. I now have a code for Tulip Clothing. Use the code, MARSHA20, for 20% off your order. I’m proud to say I also have a code for Lintico. Please use LINTICOMBK for 10% off your purchase. In case you didn’t know, bloggers must disclose the use of affiliate links. That’s why I include this in each post.

Where you can find me:

Linking up with Nancy’s Fashion Style,  Is This Mutton, and Shelbee on the Edge. I also link up with I do deClaire, Mummabstylish, and Style Splash as well as the Senior Salon Pit Stop and Slices of Life. Please check out these wonderful ladies and their blogs! I also am a co-host for Ageless Style on the third Thursday of the month and Songful Style on the last Monday of the month as well as the Global Writing Challenge on the second Thursday. I now co-host Fashion Files with Amy at Coffee and Cocktails at the Casa every Tuesday. I co-host Traffic Jam Weekend every Thursday with Melynda, Lisa, Cat, and Rena. I also host 10 on the 10th on the 10th of the month! I do hope you’ll check out all of these blogs and link parties!

3 Comments

  1. Smart move to use the towel for an apron! I remember seeing that here as well. Flashback!
    I hadn’t heard of the artist before, very interesting, thank you.

  2. Wow, it seems to me she was way head of her time. And it always surprises me that in that ara women were supported to go to school! Sometimes it looks like there is not much changed in a century. And I don’t mean technology wise. It’s a lovely painting! So much to see!

  3. Thank you Marsha, I love the colour of your dress.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.